Rosellini's '60s toll idea deserves another look

Remember the old saying: Hindsight is 20-20?

If only Washington voters had followed Gov. Albert Rosellini’s tolling plan to build, maintain and replace our state’s major bridges, we would have replacement funds today.

Now, lawmakers in Olympia are scrambling to find the billions needed for the new I-5 bridge connecting Vancouver and Portland. Predictably, tolling needs to be included in the funding scheme, but it is still a political hot button.

Rosellini, the Seattle Democrat elected governor in 1956, staked his political career on tolling. In the early 1960s, he proposed four new toll bridges which are vital traffic arteries today.

While he eventually won approval for the bridges, he lost his re-election bid in 1964. In effect, we all lost the ability to fund future infrastructure from reserve accounts that would be established from permanent tolls.

Just as the original I-5 bridges across the Columbia River were built with tolls, those tolls ended when the construction bonds were paid off. Drivers paid 5 cents to cross the Columbia between 1917 and 1929. Then when the second structure was completed in 1958, they were assessed a 20-cent crossing charge until 1967.

Rosellini supported building toll bridges across the Hood Canal, Lake Washington and the Columbia River (not in Vancouver). When he proposed making the tolls permanent he was pummeled by voters who were convinced lawmakers would simply divert the excess collections to fund other state programs. Unfortunately, legislative history worked against Rosellini.

So the last of the Rosellini tolls came off the Highway 101 bridge connecting Astoria and the Long Beach Peninsula in Washington.That occurred on Dec. 24, 1993.

The heart of Rosellini’s proposal was in Seattle.

As a way to alleviate traffic congestion on the l-90 Lake Washington floating bridge, Rosellini championed construction of a second floating bridge. It would cost $21 million and be built across the lake starting at the south end of the University of Washington campus.

Rosellini proposed a 35-cent permanent toll in each direction and wanted to put surplus money aside for repairs, modifications and eventual replacement. Unfortunately, voters again insisted the tolls end when construction bonds were retired. In 1979, toll cubicles were converted to bus stops.

The replacement bridge costs climbed to over $4.6 billion. In May 2009, Gov. Chris Gregoire signed legislation authorizing a new toll of $3.59 each way during peak commutes.

The stark reality is without tolls, vital bridges would not be constructed. It has been that way for a century.

As taxes collected from a gallon of gas diminish at the state and federal levels and as more electric and hybrid vehicles plug our highways, future transportation funding hinges on user fees.

Even in metropolitan areas with good light-rail, commuter train and bus systems, traffic congestion remains a growing problem. Unfortunately, the costs to alleviate the glitches continues climbing.

When President Eisenhower pushed construction of the interstate highway system in the 1950s, land was commonly purchased by the acre in open areas. Today, it is mostly procured by the square foot in densely packed cities and suburbs.

Our state’s economy is built on moving products and people along our highway networks. While we are blessed with the Puget Sound, Lake Washington and the Columbia River, we are cursed with finding ways to fund crossing them.

It makes sense for lawmakers to revisit Rosellini’s strategy to “pay forward” our bridges. Likewise, it is incumbent upon our legislators to establish “locked boxes” devoted to depositing excess fund to be withdrawn only to repair, maintenance and replacement of our state’s major bridges.

We have “untouchable” accounts for workers compensation. Why not for key bridges?

Don C. Brunell is a business analyst, writer and columnist. He retired as president of the Association of Washington Business, the state’s oldest and largest business organization, and now lives in Vancouver. He can be contacted at [email protected].